Sarasota, FL Pizza

Loooove Valentino!!! Best pizza in town and their customer service is TOP!!! One of our family's favorite.

I have never eaten in this restaurant, not have I had their pizza, but let me tell you ... Their cheesecake is FABULOUS! I ordered a whole one for a birthday and WOW! I'l ... more

First time here. Ordered NY pie to go. Very tasty and ready on time.

This place is great! The food is amazing and the service is amazing you can't ask for anything else.

Best Roman style pizza Ive pizza ever eaten! The tomato sauce, the cheese, all the toppings, are so much better than anywhere else. The crust is food magic! Great owners, ... more

We absolutely love this pizza! My kids always ask for it. We each have our favorites and just love the staff and owners. Dietary restrictions: Cauliflower crust pizza

Very good pizza! Vegetarian options: They had good options

In my neighborhood but Id travel miles for them wings

Best pizza in town! Absolutely love this place. Always consistent too.

Delicious crust, wonderful flavor.

I'm convinced these 5 star ratings are fake. Ordered delivery last night. 2 pizzas and an order of garlic knots. There was no sauce or cheese over most of the pizza. It w ... more

Over an hour wait with an empty restaurant. Thats insane. Thought Id try yall but rather go to Shaners

Bread soft, cheese steak enough meat for big appetite, very clean and inviting..just too quiet..no music or yelling no f bombs or horns beeping..so it ain't the city but ... more

Nice staff! Great food with fresh toppings. A must visit!

Best pizza in town . Friendly staff. Seating outdoors was pleasant Special offer was good, $10.99 two (big) slices of pizza and a 20 oz. drink

Best Meatball Sub Ever

Nice spot in this part of town Parking: Street. Maybe difficult at times

So much for a 16 pizza.

This was one of the best Italian meals including our time in Italy! A must good to!

Amazing food! Good people work here! Amazing food all around! Calzones are scrumptious I must say! Look forward to visiting Sals every time we visit The cannolis are supe ... more

Food was excellent and service was great!

Pizza delivered LATE, after an hour we live minutes away. It was barely warm...THICK DOUGHED crust We loved the one one in Gulf Gate in the past. I've lived in Sarasota f ... more

As someone from New England, I have to say, this might just be the best pizza I've ever tasted! It's absolutely flawless!

Stopped in for a beer and a few slices of pepperoni. The pizza was delicious. Authentic foldable NY style. The crust was good, not too thick or thin. Tastes like your ave ... more

Parking: ok

Outstanding every time. We can always count on Shaners.

The pizza is pretty good, although it's a bit expensive. The restaurant is a bit run-down looking, although overall, I'd recommend. The service was good, staff was friend ... more

Grew up in Sarasota, and make sure we eat at Demetrio's just about every visit. Love their Pizza and Greek Salads.

Extremely poor customer service. Ordered 2 10 Pizzas this evening on 4/5/2024 at 7:20pm. Was told 40 minutes for pickup. Arrived at 8:00pm and the younger gentleman at th ... more

Seems like a place struggling to stay open. Order pizza with basil on phone, ready in 20 minutes. All pizza is hand thrown. not bad

The pizza is awesome. Very fast service. Attentive waitress.

Take out pizza. It was awesome.

Monday Trivia, Thursday Karaoke. Excellent cocktails and friendly staff with a family atmosphere. A must for pizza night

Came in for a couple slices and the pizza was some of the best Ive had in a long time!

Love your delicious pizza . Different variates and selection on healthy drinks . Salad bar is good too . One of the best pizzas I had in my life . Its thin crust so you d ... more

Delicious deep pizza Dietary restrictions: Gluten free options

All I can say is you guys rock! Always love having a friendly work neighbor- from the club of 7s!

This location has a bad habit of omitting key ingredients. Specifically, the latest was the ham that was supposed to be on our antipasta salad--it's the first listed ingr ... more

Gabby was awesome. Very professional and very friendly and made an extra effort to help us with the special of the day, we appreciate her!