Poppy's Pizza, LLC

Aug 2nd, 2021

Good food, Good service. I had Long Island 12”. The crust was light and crispy and the food was flavorful. The waitress was very polite and attentive.
Jul 29th, 2021

We didn't have a good experience here. I tried calling twice on a Thursday during the lunch hour and no one answered. I decided to try calling again on Friday and and each time it appeared to be answered, but complete silence as if it was muted. The girl at the counter said it must be a phone glitch. We ordered a large Westchester to go. When my husband held the box, he wasn't sure a pizza was in it because it was so light. The pizza was dry (no sauce at all), there was a miniscule amount of spinach, and it's pretty expensive for hardly any ingredients. We eat pizza about once a week, and we both thought this was the worst pizza we ever had. The girl taking the order was pleasant, so I appreciate that, but I would not order here again.
Jul 25th, 2021

After finding almost nothing open in old town on a Tuesday night we found Poppy’s! My friend put together a BYO pizza with pepperoni, green Chile and pineapple. Awesome combo - spicy green Chile, huge pepperonis and just the right amount of cheese. Super friendly chef/owners! Pair it with a Boxing Bear cider (next door) and perfection!
Jul 23rd, 2021

The real deal great pizza the best yet I'm a New Yorker form Yonkers I thought I was back in the old neighborhood
Jul 3rd, 2021