Gotham Bagels

Mar 24th, 2022

Amazing sandwiches. Only complaint is their delivery radius is so small that we cant get it delivered to Logan square, just 2.5mi away.
Mar 17th, 2022

The bagels and sandwiches were good, although a little salty/tough, likely due to the kitchen trying to rush the orders out since two sandwiches took over an hour. Portions on the corned beef were a little sparse for the price-something probably seen across all Chicago bagel shops. Eager to give this another try and update my review, but will be waiting until the restaurant is able to figure out supply/demand/wait times (went to order today but online orders are closed since the kitchen has reached capacity at 11:30 on a Saturday-also can only order through online) Update: went back again recently and the sandwich was great. Portions were bigger, less than 15 min wait from time to order, bagel was nice texture. Potential update to 5 once I give it a try in peak/weekend hours. Thank you! Further update: bagels have improved, service has not nor have they quite figured out how to handle busier times. Can only recommend ordering at non peak times and avoid weekend orders. Bagels 4.5* but not being able to get even an unsliced bagel at 11 on a Sunday makes it a very niche bagel place..
Mar 16th, 2022

Definitely NYC style bagels. The rockys Deli is an absolute delight.
Mar 12th, 2022

Great bagels!
Feb 17th, 2022