Lancaster, PA Italian Restaurant

Best NY style pizza ever! Delicious and good service. Too bad I have to go to the mall but great job. No one around here knows how to make this style. We will be back

Decent pizza. Very over priced. The price of 2 slices & a drink was $11.. Again, it was good pizza... But I will probably eat at a different food court shop next time bec ... more

Pizza and mozzarella wedges are amazing!

0 common courtesy here dont recommend wasnt treated well customers behind me asked if the staff knew me from the way they treated me

We enjoyed our dinner and very delighted with our server, Kat. She's pleasant, kind and making sure we're taken care of. Good food always! Wheelchair accessibility: Wide ... more

This isnt the first time I was at this Olive Garden, and the Alfredo was sticky, thick and flavorless. In addition, the last time I was at this Olive Garden for lunch, th ... more

Wonderful.

It was a busy Saturday night so service was a little slow. Expected.

Great pizza

Great pizza. Best place in Lancaster

Picked up some meatballs and their fries from a delivery service a few years ago and enjoyed them immensely. When COVID hit, they had to shut down and at the time, it was ... more

Generous portions of delicious food. Have been there twice as part of a party, and the timing of the courses was absolutely perfect!

Incredible service and great food! Highly recommend!

Food : 5/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 5/5 More

Loved everything about this place. The food & drinks were phenomenal. Our server (faith) was fantastic . Atmosphere was very romantic and class. Highly recommend!!!

I've never had a bad meal here the food is amazing I've tried new things I've never even heard of before and everything comes out top quality 100%, the best! Staff is alw ... more

Ordered on wednesday afternoon around 2pm. Pizza was good and price is very reasonable. Value 9/10 taste 8/10. Chicken wings sauce flavor was good but wings didnt look co ... more

Food is great

The pizza is to die for!!

Delicious very nice. Everything very good.

CarryOut/small dining area pizza joint. We drove by and stopped on a whim, ...great decision. Friendly staff and excellent food. 'There's always room for pizza', especial ... more

We always went here for lunch now they raised prices ,made the breads smaller and forget your order. What happened??

Thank you Ryan for your awesome service! Food was magnificent! The salmon was melt in your mouth delicious! Atmosphere was relaxing. This was our first visit to Gibraltar ... more

Genuine NY style pizza. Pretty good too.

I had not eaten at Columbo's in over 10 years. Stopped in to grab one of their tuna salads. Although the price has gone up due to all this wonderful inflation we have to ... more

Very mediocre nothing negative about the experience but nothing about the food atmosphere or staff left me wowed. Not a bad place to eat but there are so many other optio ... more

The food was good and the service was very good.

The food really was pretty good but the thing I remember most was the waitress because she noticed a birthday card on the table and she went out of her way to bring a spe ... more

Amazing cheesy beard