Joe Theismann's Restaurant

While I was a grumpy guest when I walked in for a lot of reasons, Benjamin's service was textbook excellence. His verbiage, menu tour, suggestions, pace, communication, honesty, and deference were among the best I've ever experienced, anywhere at any level of dining. Bravo, and sorry I was grumpy!
Mar 27th, 2023

I have eaten dinner here many times in the last ten years or more. It is always a pleasant experience with consistently good food and service. Even though they have remodeled several times I still feel like I am in the same place. Lately I have had Kellan as a server. He is so friendly and personable and does a good job. Even if he is really busy I always get excellent service! I also had Rob as a server one night and he also did a great job. Thank you for many delicious meals.
Mar 27th, 2023

The nicest people, delicious food, great service, and a perfect characteristic and welcoming atmosphere! This whole experience was wonderful, primarily thanks to Taylor, who served our table and was incredibly informative, kind, and accommodating. Highly recommend!!
Mar 23rd, 2023

I have not been to Joe Theismann's in about 15 years. I remember it being very lively, but couldn't remember how I felt about the food. After reading the reviews, we decided to try it. We found parking right outside the restaurant, which was nice. As I remembered, it was pretty crowded and lively. Sports bar vibe but with a mature crowd. Casual atmosphere. We sat closer to the back near the TV. Our server was pleasant but I don't remember her name. For drinks, we had hibiscus lemonade. They said it was freshly made but I couldn't tell. Definitely tasted like it came out of a machine. Too sweet for my taste but it was fine otherwise. We had the lemon pepper wings for appetizer. If you love lemon pepper seasoning, you will love these. They seasoned the heck out of those wings, and they were piping hot. For dinner we had the Chicken Louisiana and the Blackened Salmon. Both dishes were delicious but neither was hot. My salmon was hot but the rest of the dish was lukewarm. That was a disappointment, but I was hungry and the flavors were on point so I ate all it anyway. We left no crumbs! For dessert we had the ten layer chocolate cake. Ten layers? Where? Maybe they are counting the icing as a layer. If you are looking for real cake, I don't recommend this. We took 2 bites each and packed it up to go. It wasn't bad, but definitely not what we were looking for. It was also cold so maybe that played a part. I will let it sit out today and give it another try. Overall service was decent. Our server was gone a little longer than we would have preferred but it was crowded and I could tell she was doing her best to get to all her tables. So if you come on a busy night, bring your patience. I look forward to going back. I am still thinking about the salmon dish. Whew!
Mar 23rd, 2023

Food : 5/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 5/5 More
Mar 22nd, 2023