New York City Pizza
-
81 Pope Ave A
Hilton Head Island, South Carolina 29928 - 843-842-2227
Hours
Chamber Rating
-
David Burke
Excellent pizza and wings!!
Apr 3rd, 2024 -
Jane Whitcomb
If it wasn't for the food, this would be a nice place! Ordered a large pizza which was delicious, except it was raw in the middle. A diameter of 8" of the middle was inedible because of uncooked dough! Sad to report that he Smash Burger was also awful. They must not know how a Smash Burger is supposed to be presented: it's supposed to have a crispy crust. This burger was just a soggy blob and was unpalatable. The place was almost empty, so it couldn't be blamed on being too busy. The pizza was very tasty - maybe they need a new cook?
Apr 1st, 2024 -
KK Flowers
I ordered a burger online through GrubHub for pickup. It told me that the wait would be 25-30 minutes. Before the time was up I got a text saying 40-50 minutes. With 5 minutes left before the 50 minutes was up I walked to the restaurant because my hotel is behind them. Once I get to the restaurant I head to the bar to pick up my order. After giving the bartender my name and showing her the confirmation it didn't show so it took her a minute to finally confirm my order. Then she asked for me to pay when I already did online. Once that was confirmed she said that they were just starting to make my order. So I'm waiting for an additional 20 minutes. So I get my food, arrive back at the hotel and now notice that my fries are not in the bag. If the NCAA tournament wasn't on I would have gone back to voice my concern. Extra long wait and then only give me half of my order.
Apr 1st, 2024 -
Olivia Callahan
Thought it was hard to mess up a pizza.. they did it. Ordered a vegetarian pizza and Mediterranean salad. Sauce was completely flavorless, cheese was nasty and chewy. Salad dressing was thick and way too sweet. 0/10 would never return. Dominos is better..
Mar 28th, 2024 -
Steve Goodreds
Never any good. Tasteless crust or sandwich bread
Mar 27th, 2024
Contact Info
- 843-842-2227
Questions & Answers
Q What is the phone number for New York City Pizza?
A The phone number for New York City Pizza is: 843-842-2227.
Q Where is New York City Pizza located?
A New York City Pizza is located at 81 Pope Ave A, Hilton Head Island, South Carolina 29928
Q What is the internet address for New York City Pizza?
A The website (URL) for New York City Pizza is: https://www.newyorkcitypizza.com/
Q What days are New York City Pizza open?
A New York City Pizza is open:
Thursday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Saturday: 11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Sunday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Monday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Tuesday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Wednesday: 11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Q How is New York City Pizza rated?
A New York City Pizza has a 3.8 Star Rating from 1061 reviewers.
Hours
Related Categories
Ratings and Reviews
New York City Pizza
Overall Rating
Overall Rating
( 1061 Reviews )David Burke on Google
Excellent pizza and wings!!
Jane Whitcomb on Google
If it wasn't for the food, this would be a nice place! Ordered a large pizza which was delicious, except it was raw in the middle. A diameter of 8" of the middle was inedible because of uncooked dough! Sad to report that he Smash Burger was also awful. They must not know how a Smash Burger is supposed to be presented: it's supposed to have a crispy crust. This burger was just a soggy blob and was unpalatable. The place was almost empty, so it couldn't be blamed on being too busy. The pizza was very tasty - maybe they need a new cook?
KK Flowers on Google
I ordered a burger online through GrubHub for pickup. It told me that the wait would be 25-30 minutes. Before the time was up I got a text saying 40-50 minutes. With 5 minutes left before the 50 minutes was up I walked to the restaurant because my hotel is behind them.
Once I get to the restaurant I head to the bar to pick up my order. After giving the bartender my name and showing her the confirmation it didn't show so it took her a minute to finally confirm my order.
Then she asked for me to pay when I already did online. Once that was confirmed she said that they were just starting to make my order.
So I'm waiting for an additional 20 minutes. So I get my food, arrive back at the hotel and now notice that my fries are not in the bag.
If the NCAA tournament wasn't on I would have gone back to voice my concern. Extra long wait and then only give me half of my order.
Olivia Callahan on Google
Thought it was hard to mess up a pizza.. they did it. Ordered a vegetarian pizza and Mediterranean salad. Sauce was completely flavorless, cheese was nasty and chewy. Salad dressing was thick and way too sweet. 0/10 would never return. Dominos is better..
Steve Goodreds on Google
Never any good. Tasteless crust or sandwich bread
Overall Rating
Overall Rating
( 1061 Reviews )Write a Review
Pizza Near Me in Hilton Head Island, SC
TJ's Take & Bake Pizza
Hilton Head Island, SC 29926
843-681-2900 ( 126 Reviews )
New York City Pizza
Hilton Head Island, South Carolina 29926
843-689-2229 ( 374 Reviews )
Fat Baby's Pizza & Subs
Hilton Head Island, SC 29928
843-842-4200 ( 1361 Reviews )
Bella Italia Pizza
Hilton Head Island, SC 29926
843-689-5560 ( 454 Reviews )
Local Pie Woodfired Pizza
Hilton Head Island, SC 29928
843-842-7437 ( 931 Reviews )
Super Baked Pizza and Wings
Hilton Head Island, SC 29928
843-715-4880 ( 363 Reviews )
Gators Pizza & Wings
Hilton Head Island, SC 29928
843-842-0004 ( 102 Reviews )
Giuseppi's Pizza
Hilton Head Island, SC 29928
843-671-5133 ( 499 Reviews )