Georgetowne Inn

The staff was friendly and efficient, and the food was good. My boyfriend's shrimp scampi was a bit inconsistent with the sauce and my salmon could have been better seasoned, but the quality of the products was very good and the food was cooked well. We had to choose from a select menu, so I would be interested in trying more upscale food items.
Jan 1st, 2014

Nice view if you can get anywhere near the windows. Rude unfriendly greeter scolded us not to bother the guests seated there and we were dumped into some back room downstairs. Service was rude and mostly nonexistent. All of our dishes were horrible, some were very old food despite the crowd dining at the time. Server became frustrated and disappeared without taking beverage orders when we asked about beers on tap or local micro's in bottles. Buy snacks at the Incline office if you're hungry.
Jan 30th, 2012

It's been many years (10+) since I've been to Georgetowne, but I remembered being impressed with the food and general atmosphere so I was looking forward to our outing. Unfortunately, both my husband I were quite underwhelmed by a meal which was valued at $80. While there was nothing technically wrong with the food, it was more on par with what we'd expect at Eat N Park. ~View: 4 stars Pittsburgh's skyline, especially at night is stunning. ~Food: 2 stars *details below if you want them) Uninspired, bland, lots of canned rather than fresh ingredients (which is fine in some places, but I expect more from 4 star restaurant) ~Decor/General Atmosphere: 2 stars Very outdated and bit dank smelling here and there as I walked through & the bathrooms smelled unclean. Seating by the windows was very chilly, even by hubby who's not really bothered by the cold. ~Service: 2 stars Seated promptly (w/reservation); Friendly staff, but waitress wasn't around much. ~Overall: 2 stars and that's being generous with my ratings Overpriced (even with a Groupon deal) for what you get. I can overlook a lot if the food is good, but I would not go again even if prices were lower. *Food Review: Bread- fairly plain, but a good texture (chewy & soft with crusty outside). Sadly, this was probably the best part of the meal aside from the view. Cheese and crackers - fine, but nothing nothing memorable. Fried Zucchini & Pasta Marinara - both pretty standard. Butter & Garlic Pasta - no detectable garlic flavor & noodles weren't evenly coated (some pieces were dry, no butter at all) Steaks - didn't look burnt, yet had a slightly more charred taste than I would have preferred and it were also pretty uninspired. Plus the presentation wasn't so great since they were swimming in juices (which I was actually ok with b/c it helped with the taste, but it wasn't a very clean presentation). Peach Melba - I was hoping for a tasty pound cake w/fresh fruits & whipped cream, but the pound cake was pre-packaged, the peaches were clearly canned, and even the ice cream was akin to the cheap bulk party ice cream in a big plastic tub rather than a good quality ice cream. The four raspberries were fresh, which was a nice surprise.
Dec 4th, 2013

NEVER AGAIN!!!! We have been there before (about 3.5 years ago) and it was excellent. We had the opportunity to redeem gift certificates for there so we did and thought we would use them on a special occasion. Anyway, we went hungry expecting a great meal. Boy were we in for a terrible surprise!! To start the meal. 4 of us had the steak and potato soup. I was kind enough to keep my thoughts on that until the ride home. It reminded me of the left over fatty gel that remains about an hour after I'm done cooking a piece of meat in the slow cooker. My steak salad ($25) was not near as good as the steak salad I get for about half price at Outback. The Outback even serves house ranch, unlike here that served the crappy bottle ranch. After first bite, I switched to Balsalmic which was ok. As for the filet on it, I have had cheaper cuts of meat that were tastier and better quality. My sister did enjoy her filet, but her baked potato came with melted American cheese. Blew my mind for a restaurant on Mt. Washington! My father ordered surf and turf ($48) and returned his lobster because he said he has never seen lobster look that way before. The second one was acceptable, but again he has had much better for cheaper. My mother was also surprised that the butter served for their lobster did not come over a warmer, but served in a black plastic cup. As for the pasta tossed in garlic butter, it was literally sitting in a bowl of butter. Another steak at the table was not even warm. Another surprise was the fact they don't even serve fresh ground pepper anymore. I guess thats too expensive considering all of the empty tables that surrounded us, and I'm sure they are not getting repeat customers anymore. So anyway, while we were eating we pretty much decided we were never coming back. Unfortunately, when we went to pay the bill they would not allow us to use both gift certificates, so we handed it off to another table because it is definitely not worth another trip back. If their meal was anything like ours, that gift certificate made their night!
Oct 31st, 2013

This is an enjoyable experience. The car valet is $5, I don't know where you'd park otherwise. Our reservation was for 7:30 but we weren't seated until 8, so we enjoyed some time at the small cozy bar, where surprisingly they had an interesting Macallan scotch to taste. The hostess was friendly but must have been quite new, which added to the fun. The food was better than expected, shrimp scampi was full of garlic and butter and was surprisingly tasty, and my salmon was a huge piece and was cooked well. This is not super top-class food, rather, more like a nice diner that happens to be situated with an incredible view of Pittsburgh. By the way there is no way to reserve tables by the window or even to request them, you sort of get put wherever they want you, at least according to our new hostess. Prices aren't bad either, and the wine list and bar prices were very reasonable. Food presentation was lacking, but again, think of this as a nice diner on Mt. Washington and you won't be disappointed. Also there is evidently an upstairs lounge (a second bar) that might be worth checking out when it's open on busier weekends.
Jun 15th, 2013