Gaeta's Tomato Pies

Richie Pawlowski _{on Google}

Oct 19th, 2021

Wow what an amazing tomato pie! Can't wait to try the regular and white pizza. The entire undercarriage has a robust crunch not just the perfectly cooked crust. Amazing. The sauce was perfectly sweet and just chunky enough. Lastly and most importantly the staff were over the top accommodating and friendly!! I asked if they could make a tomato pie with no cheese in the sauce or on top and whoever answered the phone said "no problem we'll make you a fresh pie just tell me what time you want to pick it up and we'll have it fresh and ready for you" and sure enough I arrived two minutes early and the pizza came out of the oven hot and fresh at exactly the time I asked. Such a great customer service experience!

William “ILLWILL” McClinton _{on Google}

Oct 17th, 2021

Best tomato pie in Philly

Danny Danny _{on Google}

Oct 10th, 2021

Very good tasting tomato pie. I would have given it a 5 if the tomato wasn't cold. I arrived to pick it up exactly when they said it would be ready. Pie was obviously left on the counter for over 45 minutes to not even be warm.

M _{on Google}

Aug 18th, 2021

Greta's is the best Tomato Pie in the city, lots of delicious sauce, blend of spices and olive oil and crunchy excellent crust. No frills Bread bakery, you place your order and walk in and it's ready for you in all its glory. Friendly staff and the prices are good. This little hidden gem in the northeast is a best kept secret.