The Pufferbelly Restaurant

Great place to eat! Nice friendly service as well
Oct 25th, 2016

We had eight of us on a Friday night, the restaurant was almost empty and that's probably because the food was so bad. The steak was tough and the green noodles around it were cold. One person order crabcakes that he'd had before and couldn't even eat them. Out of the eight different meals we had only one person that felt it was any good . They even screwed up the drinks, don't order the bloody Mary's. What a disappointment for a group outing.
Jul 11th, 2015

Jun 3rd, 2015

Worst food in Erie, hands down. Dated dishes done by an obviously untrained staff using institutional and frozen food. Paid $25.00 for the "Steak Montreal" which I ordered rare. Apparently the "Montreal" seasoning is... nothing. It was cooked way over temp and obviously a frozen piece of beef due to the texture and blandness. As far as the 'atmosphere' it was dead at prime time on a Saturday night with dusty, dated, and overlit decor. Horrid electronic jazz Muzak in the dining room. And seriously where did you get your servicewear? The Salvation Army? In 1983? A ripoff unless you want soup and a club sandwich for lunch. The french onion soup is actually quite tasty. Other than that... avoid at all costs.
Feb 7th, 2015

We love the nachos and they have the best peanut butter pie in town possible the world!
Dec 22nd, 2014