Red Mill Inn

Great food and service for fair prices. Welcoming staff took great care of us despite us arriving late.
Jul 27th, 2016

It is CLOSED. 5 star for creepy appearances though.
Feb 20th, 2016

I went here for my 25th birthday. I had been spending a couple days researching the best place to go for seafood and the Seafood Cappy dish caught my eye. When we got there, it was early for a dinner service so we were by ourselves which felt odd. Our waitress was nice and never let my water glass get empty. The seafood bisque was the best soup I've ever had, no lie. My main course, the seafood cappy, was absolutely delicious. The sauce was a little heavy, but it had huge chunks of lobster and sea scallops in it. The prices were a little high, but the food was so good we didn't mind paying it. The decor kind of feels like you're eating at someone's grandmother's house though. This along with the pricing is why I rated 4 stars instead of 5.
Nov 17th, 2015

The food and service were fantastic! The staff was very friendly and our meals were delicious. The Seafood Bisque was just about the best soup we ever had. The Mediterranean Shrimp and Chicken was an excellent choice and we also really enjoyed the Fish Fry. The homemade desserts were amazing (the Almond Florentine cookies are a must have!) Reasonable prices, excellent food, great service...we will be back!
Aug 21st, 2013

This was an awful experience. It started with the phone call to make reservations and carried through to 5 completely overcooked dinner, dirty water glasses and a snooty waiter. The friend food was burt to a crisp and the Chicken Toscana Pasta was a soupy, luke-warm mess that only my 16 month old daughter would eat. We went there hoping for a nice meal and between the dirty decor, floors, and dishes combined with horrible meals and service. We will never return OR recommend this restaurant. One little funny tip is that they do give you a coupon with your check. If you have to give a coupon to your guests to return, that should be a clue something has gone horribly wrong!
Apr 22nd, 2013