Oath Pizza - East 67th Street

Food : 4/5 | Service : 4/5 | Atmosphere : 3/5 More
Mar 24th, 2023

Really nice pepperoni pizza. The staff is very friendly
Mar 12th, 2023

Akeem was so wonderful in making me the best gluten free classic pizza with the chick pea crust. He is very warm and friendly. An asset to the 1143 3rd avenue store. Written on Valentine's Day. From Marjorie Food : 5/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 5/5 More
Feb 16th, 2023

Hakim and Sawanda are the best customer service Ive ever had. Their attitudes are absolutely amazing and theyre a pleasure to speak to. They attend to you like youre a guest at their house. Now for the food, every pizza Ive tried has been a 10/10. Even their dessert cookie pizza was delicious. I recommend this place to ANYONE that is hungry.
Feb 15th, 2023

I have so many issues with Oath Pizza. For the positives: The order came fast and nicely packaged, and they offer a chickpea pizza crust. Now, the negatives: SO OVERPRICED. And they are stingy with ingredients even though you pay a ridiculous amount! I don't understand this, but my pizza didn't have ANY tomato sauce. NONE. I didn't see an option to remove or add this, so it makes no sense. They also did not add the ricotta cheese and ranch that I paid for. The pizza was only edible because I dipped it in ranch I have at home. The Caesar salad I received had NO Caesar dressing?! Maybe they forgot it, I don't know, but besides that the salad was maybe 5 bites. Over $2 a bite. And it comes with their "housemade croutons" which they seem to be proud of and are the WORST croutons I have ever tasted in my life. I tried 2, picked the rest out and threw them away. Dried, chewy, flavorless pieces of flatbread. They need a price and quality check asap. PS. Check the reviews on Seamless and Grubhub from people who ACTUALLY ate Oath Pizza, because there are definitely some fake reviews on here.
Mar 7th, 2023