Truffle Honey Eatery
Restaurant, Steak House, Pizza Restaurant
3943 NY-394 suite 2 Mayville, NY 14757Excellent service, with truffle flavors you can't really get anywhere else in the area in a upscale casual atmosphere.
Bellini Lounge
Restaurant
215 W Lake Rd Mayville, NY 14757I can't say if the food was good or not because they didn't put my food in right and I didn't have time to wait for a redo... but the server was nice. It's nice inside, n ... more
Music For Your Mouth
Restaurant
21 S Erie St Mayville, NY 14757Food was good, unique atmosphere, a bit more money than I generally want to spend, but good overall
Webb's Carryout + Cafe
Coffee Shop, Takeout Restaurant, Store
115 W Lake Rd Mayville, NY 14757Inaccurate listing of hoursnot open during the winter
The Best of Buffalo by Byron - Food Truck
Restaurant, Caterer, Mobile Caterer
Varies--->https://easyeats.xyz/menu/f/ind/fid/474, Water St Mayville, NY 14757Best Buffalo wings Ive had in the area, comes out hot and crispy along with delicious curly fries
The White Carrot
Fine Dining Restaurant
4717 Chautauqua-Stedman Rd Mayville, NY 14757Celebrated our anniversary here. We had excellent service and the meal was amazing. We enjoyed the smaller portions, as we were able to focus more on the subtle tastes an ... more
Mayville Diner
Diner, Restaurant
7 W Chautauqua St Mayville, NY 14757Its ok i guess
MexiCali Munchie Co
Restaurant
21 S Erie St Mayville, NY 14757The pizza was delicious! I don't know how they do it, but the crust was amazing. Definitely worth the trip!
Boxcar Barney's - Seasonal Hours May - Labor Day
Dessert Shop, Coffee Shop, Ice Cream Shop
13 W Lake Rd Mayville, NY 14757Unique and delicious flavors paired with large portions! A perfect place for a quick ice cream dessert.
Olde Corner Deli
Sandwich Shop
6344 County Touring Rte 54 Mayville, NY 14757Great food !
Watermark Restaurant
Seafood Restaurant, Bar, Steak House
188 S Erie St Mayville, NY 14757I ordered a New York strip with the blue cheese topping. They literally brought me a New York strip with blue cheese dressing on top. I thought it was a joke.
Olive's At Chautauqua Suites
Italian Restaurant
215 W Lake Rd Mayville, NY 14757So glad to be able to get back to Olives for our anniversary. Great meal great service. Make a reservation soon you won't be sorry.😊ðŸ˜
House On the Hill
Restaurant, American Restaurant
186 S Erie St Mayville, NY 14757Great sandwich...great customer service
Chautauqua Harbor House Restaurant
Family Restaurant, Diner
95 W Lake Rd Mayville, NY 14757A local diner with a filling breakfast.
Andriaccio's Restaurant
Miscellaneous, Bar, Caterer
4837 W Lake Rd Mayville, NY 14757We love their service, atmosphere, and food.. especially their white clam sauce, calamari, cocktails, bread, pizza, and more..
Docks
Seafood Restaurant
7 Water St Mayville, NY 14757Cozzi!
Webb's Captain's Table Restaurant
American Restaurant, Banquet Hall, Restaurant
115 W Lake Rd Mayville, NY 14757We ate at Webb’s one week ago and have removed it from our go-to list of good restaurants. We sat inside, where there were too many flies to count. When we brought the ... more
La Fleur Restaurant
French Restaurant, Fine Dining Restaurant, Restaurant
5031 W Lake Rd Mayville, NY 14757Delicious traditional French cuisine on par with the very best restaurants worldwide. You will not be disappointed.
Chautauqua Suites Hotel & Expo Center
Hotel, Convention Center, Lounge
215 W Lake Rd Mayville, NY 14757This is a clean hotel in a great location but extremely lacking in hospitality and comfort. No hot water for two mornings and very little water pressure so showering was ... more
Crosby's - Mayville
Pizza Restaurant, Convenience Store, Gas Station
14 N Erie St Mayville, NY 14757Terrible management. The manager there is completely unprofessional, she has no respect for the customers, and certainly no respect for her employees. I can't tell you ho ... more