New York German Restaurant

Meh. I love this type of food, and this was decent, but I had a lot of issues. The bread is fresh and tasty and crispy, but for almost $17, there needs to be more topping ... more

I recommend the sliders they are very tasty. Thanks to Andy for being helpful and guiding me with the menu

Great

The best kebab in New York

Food was delicious really enjoyed the burger and BBQ pork belly. The grapefruit beer was really good and service was excellent. We'll definitely go back and try other thi ... more

Far too expensive for portions that are too small

Best place in the neighborhood i love coming here to eat donor Kebeb with some fries. Best combo ever!! Shot out to shahir and Tauseef for always serving the best

Really delicious German bratwurst (also with sauerkraut) and delicious mulled wine. Super nice people who convey a little German feeling of home. A must for everyone. P.S ... more

Food : 5/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 4/5 Recommended dishes Burgers & Sandwiches, Bratwurst, German Pretzels, Steak Sandwich More

Awesome place great food omg

German home-cooked food and a good accordian player. Good time.

Horrible customer service

Great food. Friendly atmosphere. Really nice staff. Stumbled in this place by mistake and loved every aspect of the place

Best chicken salad ever

They will be missed. This was the best German restaurant I've had the pleasure of eating at.

Amazing food. Perfect setting. Definitely coming back here soon

This is my favorite place in the neighborhood.

Great food BUT shutting down as of Mother's Day 2018

Exceptional food, nice staff, consistently good ambience. They charge reasonable pricing and the food quality is great. Kudos.

We had poorly prepared dishes: from soup to dessert it felt like the chef forgot to look up the basic recipes, or how to add flavor and texture to the food. We had to sen ... more

Very bummed that this place has closed. They used to host a weekly screening of a German crime drama for those wishing to brush up or continue their language studies. I ... more

We had a great experience with the food and staff, very welcoming and will definitely be going back.

Great food and beer. Very authentic setting and atmosphere. The barkeeper Uli was a pleasure. Would highly recommend.

Wonderful place, decor is great, all with a German theme. Food was absolutely delicious! ! Staff was great. Unfortunately, they are closing 2/24/19

great food and great, friendly service. the restaurant is very cold

Simply the best, amazing service and food. Laurie was amazing 10-10 ! Will be back for sure. A hidden gem for west Seneca.

Food : 4/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 4/5 More

Amazing food, great service, large portions! Bring an appetite!!!

Cozy, intimate setting with attentive servers and great food!

With a cosmopolitan clientele, great draft beers, and a selection of locally-made German style sausages, Black Forest is a great place to hang out with a drink or a light ... more

Great beer garden for family and kids. Outdoors or indoors, they have it all.

I went here for a birthday party . Food, drinks and atmosphere was top notch. Highly recommend

Love the German salad, the pretzels. They have really nice German beer for like $4 a pint something not expensive at all. The best thing has to be the fried veal cutlet w ... more

No more

Great foot,service and a happy atmosphere

Went there yesterday for the first time. Everything was excellent from the waitress to the food. Highly recommended.

Authentic German cuisine, great beer menu and a nice atmosphere. The staff is always friendly and they go out of their way to make sure you have a good time.

First time at the restaurant celebrating my son's birthdays. Friendly environment and delicious food. We loved the large portionsand the reasonable prices.!!! Great place ... more

Excellent Brie and pumpernickle.

One of the better bars on Stone st. Try out the Belgian draft beers.

Poor service from bartenders, they were on their phones most the time. Wont ever return, do not recommend.

Great atmosphere / terrible food

I celebrated my birthday today in this excellent restaurant. happy to tell that it was a fine evening and the place was absolutely one of the reasons for the fruitful eve ... more

Food was fantastic, definitely recommend the honey cake for dessert

I made reservations to take my wife out to dinner with the family as she's been wanting to try out this restaurant. We were quite shocked to pull up to an empty lot nobod ... more

Good better and fun place to hang around with friends

My cousin and I had a great time at the Heidelberg. Being German I'm always a bit hesitant to visit German restaurants outside of Germany. Many times I had to relativize ... more

I was pleasantly surprised! The food was so good! The fries were very good and that was probably the best sausage Ive ever had! The staff was cool and very friendly.

Awesome Yurt bar. Got takeout from the restaurant. Very good food and atmosphere.

Food is great. One of the best Doners around. But the service is uninterested. The lady seemed annoyed I was ordering. And the price point of $16 with tax is too high.