Piece O' Cake

Amazing cake for our 6-2-12 wedding! Thank you!
Apr 13th, 2014

I have used Piece o' Cake and NORMALLY they are great. This time, however, they totally dropped the ball. I ordered my cake 4 months in advance and spoke to several of the staff. I went in to the store. They told me that they couldn't deliver it because it was just a sheet cake. I told them I would pick it up as I normally do. They were nasty and rude. I called the day before the party just to confirm that I would pick up my cake. They deliberately "couldn't find my order" NEVER USE THEM. MAKING A COMPLAINT WITH BBB
Jan 23rd, 2013

I received my wedding taste testing box. I was recommended to use the bakery but I'm not sure. I went through my coordinator however, the taste testing was not successful. I recommend taste testing right in the bakery because our box was in the fridge for 2 hours and cause the buttercream frosting became hard. Is that how my cake will taste on my wedding day? The Vanilla Cake and fillings were okay but not great. I was expecting something more from all the hype I received.
Apr 5th, 2012

My wedding venue gave us Piece O' Cake as an option to do our cake. I emailed them several times and no one got back to me. I also called several times with no response. I would NOT recommend this place to anyone!
Dec 21st, 2011

Piece o'cake was recommeded to me by Nancy at the Avenue as I'm having my wedding there. My girlfriend that lives in Lincroft also suggested them before I made an appointment for a tasting. Upon my arrival there were 2 separate couples that came to pick up their anniverary cakes and before leaving the door both couples mentioned that their wedding guests are still raving about their cakes. Funny enough they both had the rasberry mouse so I just had to try. The best part, Joely the owner is the no fuss owner super down to earth and was very accomodating with a collaberated cake design of 3 different photos that I chose from her gallery to make my wedding. Can't wait to see the outcome, I too chose the rasberry mouse on chocolate cake on 2 of the 4 layers. The other 2 layers are yellow cake with peanut butter mouse that's pretty outrageous!
Mar 28th, 2012