Amy J's Pasty

Incredible value!! Delicious pasty!
Sep 28th, 2021

Sep 14th, 2021

Sep 12th, 2021

I have been visiting the UP for 8-9 years and always get a pasty because it’s the thing to do. I sometimes wonder why people like these dried out, bland tasting meat & canned veggies that are shoved into a pie crust! I decided to try somewhere new and my bf spotted Amy Js while we were on our way to a different place with excellent reviews. We ordered one large pasty and two farmers cookies. With out high hopes my boyfriend cut it in half and I immediately noticed the difference! It looked fresh! Real potatoes, real carrots, the meat looked perfect.. we took a bite at the same time and both said mmmm 😋! I was in shock and so was he! This far exceeded our expectations as the countless times I’ve had bad experiences! I went in and ordered 4 more to go for my freezer and a dozen farmers cookies! I complimented the well dressed older gentleman and was on my way! I believe this shop has changed my mind about pasty’s! It’s honestly about the ingredients! The customer service was top notch as well! They made me a believer that all pasty’s are not created equal! Give them a try!
Oct 18th, 2021

Enjoy rude service if you come in wearing a mask!
Aug 23rd, 2021