American Seasons

Warning, do not try to cancel your reservation or you will be charged! The server did not show up to the table for 20 minutes after we sat down and there were only 3 tables with customers at that time. The food was sub par and well over priced! Also you will likely leave hungry if you only order an entree. Spent over $150 on two people to leave hungry and disappointed.
Oct 29th, 2023

Thrilled with my experience. Waiter was attentive. Pace and follow up was top notch. Food was delicious and inventive. Fish high quality and fresh. Highly recommend.
Sep 14th, 2023

Fantastic
Aug 31st, 2023

Fantastic spot right on the edge of the center of town. Service was superb--friendly, attentive, and helpful. Food was fantastic. Fish fresh and perfectly cooked, everything season nicely. Exactly what you hope for when eating out on Nantucket.
Aug 22nd, 2023

The food and service at American Seasons is always excellent! This is our date night place every summer. Try the burrata, the snow pea salad, the fluke and the ribeye!! The dishes were delicious, creative and we'll balanced. I'll be dreaming about how I could recreate them. The staff was friendly and calm amidst the 4th of July chaos of tourists in town. If you'd like a quiet meal with a significant other or group of friends this is your place!! A Nantucket classic that hasn't been ruined by the changing atmosphere on our beloved island. Bravo to the chef and the team!! Vegetarian options: Salads and entrees available
Jul 3rd, 2023