Aurelio's Pizza - LaGrange

One of a kind Pizzeria! Not only is it very cozy, but the service is quick and kind. Servers always check on us and make sure we are taken care of. Food hits the spot every time with always having leftovers! The prices are very reasonable but all worth it for the quality they offer! My highly recommended choices will always be the stuffed pizza, we tend to get the spinach and sausage(and/or pepperoni) as the combination is very tasty. One of my favorite appetizers will forever be the Bosco Cheese Bread Sticks. They are heavenly! The chicken Parm sandwich is also very tender and juicy I as well recommend. Definitely a nice spot to visit occasionally! Thank you for the delicious food.
Mar 28th, 2024

Pizza was good. It's parm heavy and so a little salty as others have noted. Beware if that's not your taste. Service was terrible. Took 2 hrs for a pizza dinner. Waitress seemed to only have 3 or 4 tables, but only saw her 3 times in 2 hrs. Hostess took our bill (and was working like crazy). There was plenty of help but seemed every table was waiting around.
Mar 16th, 2024

I paid $62.00 for a very dry pepperoni pizza and burnt wings and fried ravioli and cheese sticks that don't even taste cooked. Unfortunately we will not be back.
Mar 9th, 2024

In brief summary, the quality did not reflect the price. The overarching criticism is lack of attention to detail. The hostess and server were polite, but provided minimal service when there were only 3-4 tables occupied and only one carry-out order that went out the door. I ordered chicken alfredo with added sausage. The kitchen forgot the chicken and the server didnt catch or correct it, yet I was still charged the additional fee. The dish was over cooked (mushy pasta and mealy sausage), over sauced, and under seasoned. My date ordered the chicken parmesan sandwich. The kitchen forgot the marinara and cheese, which the server, again, did not catch nor correct.
Mar 8th, 2024

Maybe it was bad luck but, I ordered a large pepperoni pizza for pickup and it got everyone in my household who ate it sick with a stomach ache. The pizza was way too crispy so I'm sure that was the issue. Maybe 4 center pieces were an acceptable level of crispness. I wonder if it's cheap cheese or over baked? I'm not usually a fan or their sweet sauce but this pizza was so crispy I barely noticed there was sauce on this. Pictures speak for themselves. One picture is the pizza face up and the other is the pizza facing down. I do not recommend pizza from Aurelio's.
Mar 7th, 2024