Fenwick Islander Motel

The staff are wonderful, and it's in a wonderful location. Great views out back.
Nov 12th, 2021

Best front desk staff EVER! Laid back vibe, ocean block, and beautiful views make this a fantastic stay for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of the beach party towns.
Oct 4th, 2021

This was such a horrible disappointment! We drove 10 hours and we’re so excited for a peaceful stay….over 200 dollars a night and when we got here we were put in a room with an incredibly noisy road near, feces, flies, blood on bed, cracked and broken everything. The pictures totally misrepresented this place and we had to leave and cancel after the first night. If we had any place to go we would have never even stayed one night. I never write reviews unless they are nice but I felt a duty to let folks know that this place is nothing like their descriptions. I wish I could attach pictures because it was appalling:(
Oct 4th, 2021

Oct 1st, 2021

Zero stars. Go to the Atlantic instead - it’s right next door, has a better pool, more efficient staff, and overall more professional and a bit cleaner. Fenwick Islander would have been ok for what it was had the staff not canceled my reservation and tried to stuff eight people in a room instead. Please do not be fooled if they ask you to book through them instead of booking.com because if they make a mistake they will not take responsibility or accommodate you. They made me cancel my booking.com reservation and book through them (probably so they didn’t have to pay a fee) but advertised it as giving me a better rate. Then they canceled my reservation and blamed booking.com. When that didn’t work Karen blamed Rose. I drove 3 hours, arrived with my 4 month old infant (toddler, husband on the way) and was told we didn’t have a room. I booked months in advance and spent forever working with both hotel employees to book adjoining rooms with another family AT ROSE AND KAREN’S SUGGESTION. Karen needs help during busy season and she will blame her coworkers if something goes wrong in their absence. The manager is rude and gave me the run around before showing up the next day. Didn’t call me to discuss and when I did beg to finally have a word with him on the phone he sounded like a teenager with his first summer job - not a business owner. They must have felt bad and eventually reserved me a room but never even told me-Rose happen to find out after doing some investigating. I was very embarrassed for them but if you like small town unprofessionalism this is your spot. If you are driving from far and especially if you have kids, it is not worth the hassle - nobody likes surprises in these situations.
Sep 29th, 2021