Bay Hill Tavern

Chris Cuneo _{on Google}

Mar 22nd, 2023

Food : 4/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 5/5
Recommended dishes Big Ol' Pretzel & Dip, Fried Chicken Sandwich, Cauliflower Tacos More

Krystina Jarema _{on Google}

Mar 13th, 2023

The food was good though not absolutely memorable. One thing that really bummed me out was though we were there for the weekend brunch, they didn't have any fresh coffee. They only carry instant coffee (no decaf from my understanding) and no decaf/herbal options for hot tea. The server was sweet about it and gave me hot water with lemon but it was still a bummer. I get not having an Expresso maker but coffee is sort of a breakfast must for me.
Parking: Limited number of spots (lesa than 10 I think ) I parked at the Starbucks across the street and walked over

Scott Thielen _{on Google}

Mar 12th, 2023

Food : 4/5 | Service : 5/5 | Atmosphere : 4/5 More

Tricia A. _{on Yelp}

Mar 11th, 2023

First time visiting Bay Hill Tavern and will definitely return soon. Our server Noah was very personable and made an effort to address each of us by our names. The music playing added a great vibe to the restaurant. I had the Mac and cheese and it was absolutely delicious. I also ordered the chocolate chip skillet cookie for dessert and it was really good. It's not too sweet and very soft. I even tried my friends peanut butter banana sandwich. My next visit I plan on trying one of the pizzas. The table next to me had order pizza and they looked amazing too.