Mind Over Batter

Updated below! Quiet, extremely low key. We got cupcakes, and of course the more you purchase, the better the discount. When we visited, there were perhaps 7 or 8 cupcake/icing combinations to choose from, ranging from the tame (vanilla/chocolate icings) to tart (lemon) to fruity (raspberry, if I recall correctly). The cupcakes we got were all moist and tasty, and we quite enjoyed them. Certainly a lot better than grocery story bakeries. The prices are steeper, though, so they're more of a splurge or special occasion shop. The atmosphere did leave something to be desired - there are windows into the back room, but the lights back there were off which gave the space a hollow feel. The display cases weren't empty, but could have used more visual fill. I hope to return for another visit. :) EDIT: Visited again as part of a group celebration and very much enjoyed ourselves. We stuck around to eat and chat, this time. The staff was helpful and friendly, not too chatty but not shy, either. She was very patient with us as we worked out how we wanted to make our order, and accommodating as three households tried to get our act together. The cupcakes and icing were all still moist and fresh, not too small and not too big, and there was good variety available - and we also got two cupcakes custom made for us in short order. I definitely recommend giving them a visit, and don't be shy to ask questions, or request something not ready-made but available by the listing on their cupcake and icing list.
Feb 19th, 2017

They did our custom cake and cake pop display for our wedding! It turned out beautifully and I could never, ever get enough of their cake pops! LOVE THIS PLACE!
Feb 29th, 2016

I loved the cake they made for my baby boys 1st bday! Awesome customer service, very friendly and did exactly what we asked for! Thank u MIND OVER BATTER!
Dec 20th, 2014

I will never go there again or recomment them to anyone I associate with. Because of this special being offered through Groupon hence $15 for $25 worth of items I decided to give this a try. Well my supervisors BD is Monday today and from what's stated online via website there hours on Sunday is from 11-5pm so I get there and outside there building they are closed on Sundays. As a result I decided to contact them by phone that same day expressing my feelings of being disappointed of having to return there twice. Monday the next day I get there during my lunch hour break for the second time and I'm offered 5 different kinds to choose from yet there website offers at least 15 to choose from (false advertising in my opinion). So as I'm explaining my voicemail message I had left them on Sunday she proceeded to tell me that she had contacted Groupon already and that was it.
Jul 21st, 2016

The worst experience ever! I called about a week before I needed 2 dz cupcakes for my sons 10th birthday party. I didn't even flinch when the girl on the phone told me that it would be over $91 for the order because I assumed that I would be paying for a special and superior product. I told the girl on the phone that I would be picking up the order between 11 am and noon about 7 days later. I came at 11 am to pick up the order. The place was not open and after waiting a couple of minutes I had to call the store to tell them I was out front. When they finally opened up I was greeted by a store that was not prepped for the day and the employee looked like she just rolled out of bed. I gave the woman my order name and she went to the back to get my order. She returned and told me that my order was not made because a new hire had not completed the order the night before. She requested that I wait and she would make the cupcakes for me...$91 cupcakes made in 15 minutes. I told her that I would be back as I had to pick up something at Frys. That something being cupcakes that I ordered from Fry's for my son's classroom- I thought to order cheaper cupcakes $7.99 dz and the extra expensive special cupcakes for his actual family birthday party. Guess what, Fry's had my cupcakes ready. Anyway, I go back to MOB and she hands me 1 dozen cupcakes that are not what I ordered. I explain to her that these are not what I ordered. She goes in the back and finds my actual order and tells me that she will make the cupcakes and that on the order it states that I would be there between 11 and noon and since it was 11:50 she had 10 minutes to get me my order together. I explained to her that the whole experience had been ruined and that I no longer wanted the cupcakes. She explained that they do not offer refunds and she would have to talk to her manager who was on the phone. I gave her my phone number and told her to have her manager call me. As I was leaving the woman behind me requested her order, which was the order that had been given to me on this second visit. So if I hadn't come in first that lady would have had to wait for MOB to make her order too!!! The manager called me and apologised. She was really nice and sounded like she felt bad. She said that the owner wouldn't refund my money but would give me a discount, a refund of the custom cupcake fee, which equaled about $10. At this point I didn't have any other options for my son's birthday so I took it, an hour later I picked up the cupcakes. They refunded my $10. Really the worst part of this whole experience is that by the end of the day I felt like such an idiot for spending so much on some stupid cupcakes. I really expected something great and special. The cupcake packaging was flimsy and cheap. The cupcakes themselves were nothing special. I could have done the custom decoration. I can't even vent to friends and family because I don't want anyone knowing that the more than ordinary, less than extraordinary cupcakes they ate at my son's birthday cost me $91. What an idiot I am. Never again!
Oct 7th, 2015