Balistreri Brothers

Looking forward to trying a pizza from this restaurant at the New Berlin for quite a while. Ordered takeout large cheese, sausage, onion, and mushroom. Pizza was ready and sitting in warming area when I arrived. I was 5 min late from agreed upon time due to traffic. Entrance is on a side street as many others establishments are. Noticed right away the ordered thin crust was not fresh and hand tossed. I saw 30-40 premade crusts stacked up ready for toppings. Got it home and it was lukewarm at best. Sausage and sauce flavors were bland. Adequate distribution of sausage but didnt matter because it was so tasteless. Crust was overly chewy as you might expect from a premade source. Overall impression not good. Does not meet Ballisteri standards. I fear this location will not do well. I understand the original Ballisteris is much different. Good Luck.
Apr 8th, 2024

Thin crust sucked. reheating was pitiful. Won't be back. flavorless pizza. Tried it again and got a reheated pizza left over from day before. Crust was over cooked and soggy. Pizza was just warm - had ro throw in the oven to get it hot.
Mar 31st, 2024

Mar 30th, 2024

Mar 6th, 2024

Take out only Quick service and very friendly
Feb 2nd, 2024