Gotham Bagels

Hiren Bhavsar _{on Google}

Apr 5th, 2024

the bagels are great, but the text service to let you know when your order is ready doesn't work, so you just have to guess. Also my order was missing an item.

Pam S _{on Google}

Mar 21st, 2024

After traveling to New York and having their bagels, I never thought Id get to taste a New York bagel again.
But THIS PLACE, is LEGIT. And their breakfast bagel sandwiches are TO DIE FOR.
I will always make the drive downtown to get myself one of these!
Highly recommend the breakfast sandwich with egg, cheese, ham and add cream cheese! You wont regret it. Chefs kiss!

Belinda Caldwell _{on Google}

Mar 21st, 2024

How have we never eaten here before in our other trips to Madison? Last time I had a bagel this good, I was in Manhattan. What a treasure for lunch. We'll be back!

Eloise _{on Google}

Mar 18th, 2024

Good bagels in Madison. The bagel sandwiches are a bit pricey for the amount of toppings, but they are pretty good quality and fresh. They have lots of cream cheese flavor options. They recently reopened the dining room so you can eat in the restaurant again.