Inn On Madeline Island

Ish Sweeney _{on Google}

Nov 2nd, 2023

Freaking awesome place awesome people awesome

Kim vanderwall _{on Google}

Oct 12th, 2023

Our daughter got married there over the weekend. It was fantastic!
We originally booked the venue when another person at the Inn was managing. (She is no longer there). We were not getting much attention until Julie, the new Pub manager, took over and made it an absolute perfect weekend! Her attention to detail, get it done attitude and kind spirit was the icing on the cake. Julie was the best as well as her awesome staff! Thank you from all of our family. The bride and groom are so grateful for a memorable experience
Food & drinks: Fantastic menu!

Cory Monsour _{on Google}

Oct 9th, 2023

Amazing facility.. beautifully decorated private and dinner at the pub was exquisite highly recommend a fabulous get away
Rooms: Fresh clean private close to everything
Food & drinks: Dinner at the pub was a wonderful experience
Noteworthy details: Attention to details
White fish was so delicious
Friendly well done.

Maggie Adams _{on Google}

Sep 23rd, 2023

My fiance and I booked our room for Apple Fest. We booked here due to the location on Madeline Island and the amenities the room had along with being next store to a restaurant. The day we were going to arrive I double checked my email to ensure everything was set, I noticed it said I would get a "prepare for your stay" email that I never got so I called the Inn to make sure everything was still in order. They ensured it was and sent me the email I was missing. The email stated that the pub was open 7 days a week until Oct 22nd. Great!
We get there, the pub was closed, along with all of the common areas in the hotel, not a huge deal. We get to our room, and one of the 2 beds were clearly slept in and not changed out. The lamps next to our bed were taken off the wall. The jacuzzi (which we were most excited about) had grime/sand and hair in it. I called to have a change of sheets, no room service or anyone to answer the phone. I called the emergency number for the hotel as that was the only option and left a message. I get a call from the maintenance man, saying he will "drop off sheets" for us. I have NEVER been expected to change dirty sheets at a hotel, crazy. He did, drop off sheets. However, for an over 500 dollar stay, I'm not changing out dirty sheets. The next morning we went to the front desk and said we had some concerns we'd like to talk about regarding our room. The first thing the person at the desk said was " best thing to do is send an email". Well there's another concern - no one is here to listen? Nope. I then asked when room service would be able to clean our room. "We don't have any room service today." She explained she was just a fill in as no one in charge is there .... so for our entire stay there was no room service. We asked to have cleaning supplies sent to our room so we'd be able to try and at least enjoy our jacuzzi. She said she would see if the maintenance guy could bring us some. They ended up having someone clean our room. Only addressing the bed and the jacuzzi - no one replaced our towels when it said to leave towels on the floor for them to be replaced. I'm not sure what hotel runs without having any sort of room service, or a manager available. I've never heard of anything like that. So we were there to celebrate our engagement, but we had to worry about cleaning our own room while we were there. We were very happy with the room in general, it was a great room. Extremely disappointed with having an uncleaned room - no room service - and no real hospitality- along with having said the pub would be open, and it wasn't. I emailed the Inn asking someone to reach out to us, and have not heard a thing.
Noteworthy details: Do not expect anything to be open in the off season, and don't expect any room service apparently ! The best part of the stay was traveling to bayfield for the apple fest. If the Apple Fest was not going on, we most likely would not visit again in the fall.

Richard Erickson _{on Google}

Sep 22nd, 2023

Wonderful location on Lake Superior. Great rooms and nice area.
Pool area could use some TLC. Lots of sand on bottom, hot tub only a "lukewarm" tub. Also, gapping holes in pool fence could be fixed.
Would return and liked my stay here.
Rooms: Nice rooms. Great view of Lake.
Nearby activities: Near La Pointe and everything, which isn't much, on Madaline Island. Great spot to get away!
Safety: Doors have locks.
Walkability: Short walk to La Pointe.
Food & drinks: The Pub was nice place to eat on property.