The Pitcher Inn

Cathy Cashman _{on Google}

Feb 17th, 2024

We have been coming here for our Anniversary for the past few years and have always loved it .. This time was a huge disappointment. Called a week ahead for a reservation which they didnt have but did honor which we appreciate. The Charcuterie board was sparse and jam tasted like smuckers. Menu was very small and choices werent great . My husband had the pasta dish which was the worst Ive ever tasted . It cost $36 and probably cost the restaurant a $1 to make . My halibut was the only good thing about the meal .. but I thought it was still incredibly small proportion for price. Waitress was okay. For An upscale restaurant in Vermont too pretentious and nothing to back it up.

Gabrielle Gifford _{on Google}

Feb 8th, 2024

Had an amazing stay at the Pitcher Inn over MLK weekend. The staff went above and beyond to make us feel comfortable prior to and during our stay. Fresh croissants every morning were top notch.
We didnt get a chance to eat in their more casual pub restaurant Tracks and that is our only regret! Hope to make it back one day.

Antonio Reis _{on Google}

Jan 20th, 2024

After many years of wanting to visit, my first experience with Pitcher Inn was disappointing. My partner and I stayed in Warren at another inn but tried to visit the Pitcher for drinks and a snack. The reception staff wouldn't seat us and were quite abrupt and rude about it. I've never been turned away from an establishment by a haughty suited receptionist holding a snow shovel but I guess this is Vermont. Weird place.