Gabriella's

I just don't get why people rave about this place. We had a pizza we picked up a couple yrs ago, we weren't impressed but this yr we decided to give it another try. DISAPPOINTING. First, the " complimentary salad" was lettuce and a bit of diced tomato with Italian dressing that seemed like just oil. That's it! Bread was just thin sliced semi toasted bread. The oil for the bread was the only good thing. We both ordered pastas since our first try was unimpressed pizza. Very pricey for about $15 worth of actual food. $25+ for each and both had chicken that you barely got any of and just precooked junk. His Tortellini was like the crappy tri color stuff you buy at store, his sauce was watery not creamy. My Red pepper sauce had alil flavor though. And don't waste your money on the portabella mushrooms- you get 5 or 6 heavily breaded no flavor pieces. And our service... hated to really even tip but our server was nice enough but bit scatterbrained, we had to beg for pop numerous times, asked for lemons twice, never got our dressing for the salad that was just lettuce, and at the end we finally just walked up and asked for our bill, not like he didn't know we were done since he brought boxes. Will not be back, save your wallet and get quality italian and go to Meatball cafe!
Apr 9th, 2024

We thoroughly enjoyed the drinks, entrees, and desserts. We had the Nona's Pizza, my wife LOVED it!! The tortellini and Sausage and Peppers were excellent. You will not be disappointed. We are going back before heading home. Alex was great!! He was very attentive and responsive. Overall, the best experience we have had in a long time.
Apr 9th, 2024

This place disappointed me, the service was not very good. The food was not up to the price, I really wouldn't go again.
Apr 8th, 2024

The service was great but the food was so subpar. Definitely a tourist trap. Everything is very highly priced for low quality pizza. They use kraft mac n cheese for the kids meal, dont take the tails off of shrimp, and the food is barely flavored beyond salt and pepper. Paying $25 for a calzone that is basically just cheese and frozen spinach, and $32 for a pizza with 5 total shrimp on it is a little absurd. We will go off island for pizza next time.
Apr 8th, 2024

Definitely a tourist trap. Got the pizza with "bay shrimp" and while portions are good for the price the quality was nearly inedible for me and my party. The kids menu is microwave food for a higher price. Calzone was gobs of cheese. Stick with normal pizzas and this may be good for slightly overpriced family meals.
Apr 8th, 2024