Papa Gio's Pizzeria at Cherokee Lakes Plaza

Pizza was all sauce barely any cheese won't be back, ny style pizza has way more cheese then this...but service and environment was nice , pizza didn't really have much of a taste...
Apr 6th, 2024

Ordered a simple large pepperoni pizza and the cheese and dough were uncooked. We love the location in Irmo but definitely DO NOT plan on ordering from this location again. Its upsetting since its closer to home for us, but its really not worth having to cook it myself for an additional 20 minutes after a 40 minute round trip to pick up and get home. Disturbing. Also if you like the size of an Italian NY style pizza, this location is not it it was literally a Pizza Hut pizza.
Apr 2nd, 2024

After ordering door dash a few times while staying in Columbia I decided to call the restaurant and discuss some of the missing items. It was then told to me that it was the ordering customers fault to not ask for a fork because I quote most of our customer get food delivered to their home. Interesting strategy there. I also asked about the missing dressing for my salad. I assume this is because most of their customers carry their own dressing as well. Clearly not a place to do business with unless you are in for the night and prepared to provide basic ingredients for a meal.
Apr 2nd, 2024

I ordered from here yesterday and the salad was black and literally dirty.It was disgusting! I will never order from here again. If their salad is dirty, how can I trust the cleanliness of the establishment? I will say that the girl at the counter, Cadence, was so friendly and personable.
Mar 31st, 2024

Pizza was great!!! Garlic knots were good but in my opinion, a little dry. We enjoyed the food and the atmosphere.
Mar 30th, 2024