New York Bagelry

Bagels are always great but sometimes the service is a little slow
Mar 29th, 2024

I dont normally complain, in fact I pride myself on being understanding and patient but man was I disappointed in this visit. Im sure most of the guys there this afternoon were new and for that I can offer grace but I dont think I can come back to this location outside of the early morning when the girls are there. I came in for brunch with my mother, she ordered a tuna sandwich, I ordered 2 whole pizza bagels(4 halves; usually seasoned with garlic, oregano and basil. Ive been going here for years so I could make it in my sleep at this point because theyre my favorite), 5 bagels to go and a water. We intended to eat there but everything was packed to go. Ok no big deal. We checked everything and my moms tuna was in a small condiment container instead of what she ordered it in and what I was charged for, we were given a very small amount of regular mustard, my pizza bagels were for lack of better words lack luster and I was unfortunately over charged. We came home, did the math and added everything up including tax which landed me at around 35$ I was charged 42$. This has been a favorite spot of mine for years so I was really disheartened this time because Ive never seen my meal made with anything but love and always looked amazing. Maybe today was just an off today.
Mar 26th, 2024

Mar 24th, 2024

Mar 14th, 2024

My good friend Joe brought me here. I was very impressed.
Feb 15th, 2024