The Pump House Bar and Pizzeria

The wings were the worse wings I've had in a long time. They were dark and nasty from using old oil . They grabbed my plate without me saying anything and they saw I only ate one and never said anything..
Apr 11th, 2024

Mar 24th, 2024

This location has gone through a lot of changes and turmoil over the last few years. I wrote a lengthy review on the previous establishment there and how disappointing it was in all aspects hoping they would change and it got worse. This on the other hand is the opposite. Very good food, hand made pizza, good beer, great appetizers, good menu. Pump House brings it back to Lithopolis! I highly recommend their pizza. It takes about 30 minutes but its great quality. My only complaint is I think the pizza is a little expensive with toppings being $2.75 each putting a large easily 20+. A little steep for pizza. Other than that its solid! UPDATE; Went there again and had an outstanding experience. I was informed that they over cooked my pizza and that it would be another 35 minutes. Without reacting at all, the bartender (who has outstanding customer service) informed me that the food would be on the house and that I could get a drink at the bar as well due to my inconvenience. My wife then picked the pizza up later and was greeted by the owner (who also values his business and has great customer service). They REFUSED payment and in turn made 2 flat out AWESOME pizzas. This is not the old business, this is the new where they actually take pride in what they do and their product. Hats off to you guys and I hope your business is blessed. Its the little things like that, that will set you apart. You will see me and my entire family back again and again Update 2024; I did notice that they charge a 3% fee for the use of a credit card. Not a fan of that, feels like a nit pick. As a restaurant, I feel that they should cover that for their customers.
Mar 6th, 2024

An unexpected treat! The food was delicious, the bar and beer options were plentiful, the service was awesome, and the owner was on site and working hard to make us feel welcomed and appreciated.
Feb 26th, 2024

Feb 23rd, 2024