Baby Moon

I absolutely love the baby moon. Ive been going there since Im a child and now I am a full bloomed 56-year-old woman still loving it best Italian food and their fish is to die for absolutely prepared perfectly its not oily. The service is impeccable the the staff is very caring and acknowledge about their menu and what it consist of food arrived in a very timely manner very relaxed atmosphere. I love the fireplace and PS they make the best Shirley Temples too!!!!!!
Feb 21st, 2024

Food is incredible. Pizza is amazing. Staff is excellent. They make you feel like family
Jan 23rd, 2024

Jan 6th, 2024

Has this place gone down hill and off a cliff?! So tragic to lose what was once a bright spot in Westhampton. The relatively recent manager Carlo really knows how to nose dive a place into the ground. I feel bad for what once was. Il Giardino where John (who once ran Baby Moon) owns and runs is light years ahead of this tired, old joint, in food quality and atmosphere. If it wasnt for the memories I wouldve stopped going back years ago, but after my last meal I dont think I can put up with the inadequacy anymore. The one bright spot is Sarah the waitress. She is phenomenal. Kid-friendliness: NOT kid friendly.
Jan 1st, 2024

I saw the review from Rachel Nussbaum Barnwell, and I couldnt disagree more. I was there sitting at the bar, the same night. Ms. Barnwell was sitting at the bar, and had a 3 year old child with her. Carlo, the owner, asked her nicely, to move away from the barexplaining that children sitting at the bar, is illegal. Ms. Barnwells response was nasty, inappropriate, and disrespectful. Ive been going to Baby Moon for several years, and I have nothing but positive feelings about both the food and the service. The staff are friendly, and they work extremely hard to make sure everyone is served and attended to. The food is outstandingconsistently good. Please disregard Ms. Barnwells negative rant. Carlo was acting in the best interest of her childonly bad things can happen in that setting. Carlo doesnt deserve this, and Baby Moon is a Westhampton staple. We are fortunate to have such a great Italian restaurant here.
Dec 12th, 2023