Tony's Pizzeria

Theresa marie _{on Google}

Apr 4th, 2024

4/3/24 update something has drastically changed here, this is the 3rd pizza I've received that the crust/ pizza dough is bad! It is uncooked, flat, doesn't rise like normal. I tried to brown in my oven and it just will not brown, it just gets hard but not brown. it completely ruins the pizza which used to be my favorite. The pepperoni sub & greens & beans were delicious. Tiramasu was awesome. Tonys what is going on with your pizza crust??? Even the sausage roll is no longer tasty. Something has definitely been changed. I hope they correct or I will find another pizza place.
Love their pizza, they have the best tasting sausage of any pizza places locally. Meatballs are also delicious. Sausage roll worth the cost, very large. Greens & beans is usually very fresh & very tasty. I've had subs, as well. The only thing I wouldn't recommend is fish fry as it's frozen fish & not very good.. but overall this place has very good food.

Manuel Mannino _{on Google}

Mar 31st, 2024

I've been chasing this taste since I was a kid since Tony's was in North Utica back in the day and this place has the exact same taste 5stars for sure

Justin Gillette _{on Google}

Mar 23rd, 2024

I'm not one to complain however, stopped in and picked up two fish frys tonight 3/22/24. What I received in no way resembled a fish fry. Instead of being breaded and lightly fried, it was in a batter that formed a hard shell around the entire piece of fish. Honestly it wasn't enjoyable at all and the 2lbs of French fries (not exaggerating) didn't make up for non edible fish. I apologize for being blunt but I will not be a repeat customer.