Chamber of Commerce

      Nickel City Insurance Agency

      ( 46 Reviews )

      Nickel City Insurance Agency
      Claim Your Listing
      Claim Your Listing
      Listing Incorrect?
      Listing Incorrect?

      Hours

      Monday:
      9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Tuesday:
      9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Wednesday:
      9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Thursday:
      9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Friday:
      9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Saturday:
      Closed
      Sunday:
      Closed
      CALL DIRECTIONS REVIEWS

      Chamber Rating

      4.4 - (46 reviews)
      38
      1
      0
      3
      4
      Read Our 46 Reviews

      Chamber Rating

      4.4 - (46 reviews)
      38
      1
      0
      3
      4
      › ‹
      • Jill Lochren

        Mary is always so friendly and personable! She took care of my request immediately!
        Mar 10th, 2024

      • Susan

        Not very cordial.
        Oct 9th, 2023

      • Andrea Howell

        Great insurance agency. Mary is always very professional and willing to help. Makes insurance easy!
        Jul 3rd, 2023

      • john melock


        Jun 18th, 2023

      • Robert Justinger

        Is a very clean and detail orientated. The staff on hand is very communicative with each other and with you. So simple you lose track of time
        May 30th, 2023

      Read Our 46 Reviews

      About
      Nickel City Insurance Agency

      Nickel City Insurance Agency is located at 5532 Broadway in Lancaster, New York 14086. Nickel City Insurance Agency can be contacted via phone at 716-683-2130 for pricing, hours and directions.

      Contact Info

      •   716-683-2130

      Questions & Answers

      Q What is the phone number for Nickel City Insurance Agency?

      A The phone number for Nickel City Insurance Agency is: 716-683-2130.

      Q Where is Nickel City Insurance Agency located?

      A Nickel City Insurance Agency is located at 5532 Broadway, Lancaster, NY 14086

      Q What is the internet address for Nickel City Insurance Agency?

      A The website (URL) for Nickel City Insurance Agency is: http://nickelcityins.com/?utm_source=G&utm_medium=local&utm_campaign=google-local

      Q How big is Nickel City Insurance Agency?

      A Nickel City Insurance Agency employs approximately 2-5 people.

      Q Is there a key contact at Nickel City Insurance Agency?

      A You can contact John Gehl at 716-683-2130.

      Q What days are Nickel City Insurance Agency open?

      A Nickel City Insurance Agency is open:
      Monday: 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Tuesday: 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Wednesday: 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Thursday: 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Friday: 9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Saturday: Closed
      Sunday: Closed

      Q How is Nickel City Insurance Agency rated?

      A Nickel City Insurance Agency has a 4.4 Star Rating from 46 reviewers.

      Key Contacts

      image
      John Gehl
      Manager

      Hours

      Monday:
      9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Tuesday:
      9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Wednesday:
      9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Thursday:
      9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Friday:
      9:00 AM - 4:00 PM
      Saturday:
      Closed
      Sunday:
      Closed

      Ratings and Reviews
      Nickel City Insurance Agency

      Overall Rating

      Overall Rating
      ( 46 Reviews )
      38
      1
      0
      3
      4
      Write a Review

      Jill Lochren on Google

      image Mary is always so friendly and personable! She took care of my request immediately!

      Business Response on Google Aug 7th, 2020
      Thanks for the 5 stars Jill! Our business relationship started in January 2014 and continues to flourish by meeting both your home and auto insurance!

      Susan on Google

      image Not very cordial.

      Business Response on Google Oct 10th, 2023
      Hi Susan, I'm not sure what happened for you to feel this way. I assure you that we pride ourselves here at Nickel City Insurance to always be as helpful and as understanding to your situation as we possibly can. As President of Nickel City Insurance, I am available for you to work with at any time moving forward. I am happy to address any situation you may have, so you can feel free to speak directly to me for any help or service you may need. - Paul Justinger

      Andrea Howell on Google

      image Great insurance agency. Mary is always very professional and willing to help. Makes insurance easy!

      Business Response on Google Oct 3rd, 2023
      Thank you for your high review Andrea! Mary is certainly an asset to our Nickel City Insurance family and she does an excellent job in reflecting how we want to present a personal touch for all of our clients. Thank you for trusting us with your insurance needs for over 5 years now!

      john melock on Google

      image

      Business Response on Google Oct 8th, 2023
      Thank you John, it has been our pleasure to work with you and your insurance needs for the past 16 years! Thank you for your faith and trust in us and we look forward to the next 16 years!

      Robert Justinger on Google

      image Is a very clean and detail orientated. The staff on hand is very communicative with each other and with you. So simple you lose track of time

      Load More Reviews

      Overall Rating

      Overall Rating
      ( 46 Reviews )
      38
      1
      0
      3
      4

      Write a Review

      RATING:
      Create 1 Star Review Create 2 Star Review Create 3 Star Review Create 4 Star Review Create 5 Star Review
      Submit

      Insurance Agency Near Me in Lancaster, NY

      Giumpa Agency
      10070 Main St
      Lancaster, NY 14086
      (716) 686-0840
      ( 0 Reviews )
      Thill-Demerly Insurance Agency
      5329 Broadway
      Lancaster, New York 14086
      716-683-4491
      ( 14 Reviews )
      Herman Agency
      338 Harris Hill Rd #108
      Lancaster, NY 14086
      (716) 929-2588
      ( 0 Reviews )
      Charles Snyder: Allstate Insurance
      3725 Walden Ave
      Lancaster, New York 14086
      (716) 681-2845
      ( 115 Reviews )
      Shannon McNichol: Allstate Insurance
      5775 Broadway
      Lancaster, NY 14086
      716-288-0888
      ( 0 Reviews )
      Weimer Over Agency, Inc.
      10 Franklin St
      Lancaster, NY 14086
      716-683-3323
      ( 19 Reviews )
      Haylor Freyer & Coon
      2 Jillian Ln
      Lancaster, NY 14086
      716-686-9548
      ( 0 Reviews )

      START DRIVING

      ONLINE LEADS TODAY!

      Add Your Business
      ChamberofCommerce.com
      Loading