John C Killian MD FACS FAAOS

i think hes the best i fell off a roof and shattered my leg. he saved my leg in an 8 hour operation. The office may be disarrayed, but who cares Dr. Kilian is a Competent excellent surgeon.
May 20th, 2023

I fell off a roof and broke my leg in seven places and fractured my knee into pieces Dr. Killian doesn't have the best personality but he saved my leg in an eight hour operation I don't care how rude or how unprofessional all I know is if it wasn't for him I might not have my leg today thank you Dr. Killian .  also i had no insurance, he never hassled me for money and told me to pay what i could.  what Doctor does that?  and he charged me a schockingly low bill.
Jul 11th, 2022

This guy is the worst. I get there at 2:30pm for a 3:00pm appointment and he doesn't see me till 3:15pm and he gets me out at 3:30. I was supposed to see him two and a half months ago but he kept prolonging my appointment. There are a slew of all the issues but you will have to see for yourself.
Jan 9th, 2020

Well, all I can say about Dr. Killian is that he helped me after a terrible accident. Is was way back in 1989 when I was walking barefoot on the boardwalk at Jones Beach. I had a large splinter the size of a popcycle stick go through the bottom of my left foot under the toes and come out the left top side impaling my foot. I went to NCMC Emergency from the beach. The doctor basically just wanted to yank it out. I was screaming in intense pain. My mother contacted our family doctor. He told us to get out of there immediately and head to Mercy Hospital. So I was driven to the other hospital with the wood still through my foot on the dashboard When I arrived Dr. Killian was already there because my doctor called him. I was rushed into the emergency room where I was treated like I was the President. I was treated immediately and prepped for surgery. I had food and a glass of wine at the beach so they could not put me under anesthesia. They gave me a spinal block near the bottom of my spine. I was freaking out about having a huge needle in my back, but they gave me intravenous Valium before the block. At that point you could have done anything to me. Dr. Killian operated on my foot. I was in the hospital two days. I fully recovered. I cannot thank Dr. Killian enough for helping me get through such a terrible injury. The difference between NCMC and Mercy Hospital was like night and day. Dr. Killian was such a blessing during this most difficult time. Now over 30 years later my foot never had a problem or issue. He may have changed over the years but he was my hero at that horrible moment.
May 4th, 2022

DO NOT GO HERE!! Disaster to say the least.  I cannot say enough.  If you don't want to believe me go to Vitals.com and look up his name.  I thought it was us but when I found the reviews, they confirmed everything.  He has the personality of a rotten clam.  Not a nice person at all.  We have been to many of these IME appointments and never have we come across one that is so rude.  My husband's injuries are real & if he read the file he would have seen that.  He opened the box with the records when we arrived in the office, I couldn't believe that when the secretary told us this, over 1000 pages. He pulled his arms back (shoulder, back, hand injuries), hit him with a reflex hammer, rolled one with spikes on his arms and legs. I cannot list everything.  I was mortified. My son suggested I write a review and when I pulled him up there were at least 20 reviews and 19 he had a rating of 1 star.  They all had similar experiences.  He needs to be put out to pasture.  Dr. John Killian needs to turn in his license.  A true disgrace to his profession.
Oct 6th, 2020