All Star Bagel Toms River

Apr 9th, 2024

Had to throw out a BEC because they completely disregarded my instructions and the whole thing was a runny disgusting mess. What a waste of $7. Asked for eggs over medium they were completely runny. Cheese barely melted. Bagel mushy. Bacon undercooked when I asked for it well. I couldnt be bothered to take it back. Would not go back. 0/10 stars. Do not recommend.
Mar 29th, 2024

I am a regular customer here and I just cant get enough of their food. I at least come here 3 times a week and the service is always amazing! Breakfast or lunch I definitely recommend this bagel store!
Mar 13th, 2024

Was advertised as "NY BAGELS". Closer to the bagels you find in any supermarket in the country. Unfortunately I didn't get to experience the taste I was hoping for. **The owner's response shows the EXACT experience you can expect while visiting this establishment. They LITERALLY had a sign saying "NY Bagels" and were listed on local food searches for "NY Bagels near me" Either way save your taste buds from the torture by avoiding this place. The place is LOCALLY known as a bad place because when we told our family, who we were visiting, where we ate EVERYONE APOLOGIZED for not letting us know where we should have gone. So the owner can keep their delusions of grandeur about what the locals enjoy. **
Mar 6th, 2024

Not the same with new ownership. Missing something from pickups 3/5 times
Feb 27th, 2024