Paulie's Pizza and Wings

Apr 2nd, 2024

I've tried the other pizza places in town and haven't been impressed. Let me start by saying I don't like thick dough as my pizza crust. The other locations around town don't have flavor in the pizza sauce itself, they taste like simply crushed tomatoes out of a can. This pizza was five stars all the way around. Beautiful crisp crust and cooked perfectly on the bottom. I'm not sure where these bad reviews came from, but I met a nice lady and gentleman while there, and they were as nice as can be. This is my new pizza spot in Tenafly!
Mar 9th, 2024

Yes, the best margarita Pizza I have in NJ . The boss is so nice!
Dec 1st, 2023

I would rate 0 if I could. The owner was very rude and disrespectful cursing in store and at the employee in a different language. Did not acknowledge me at all but acknowledged other customers. She also threw a piece of paper at the employee after yelling at him. Also tried to take his tip, so disgusting to see. Dont recommend at all save your time.
Nov 23rd, 2023

This place is absolute garbage. There is absolutely no AC, no restroom, rude service. She wouldn't let me take my own back pack and yelled at my friends for sitting outside . keep in mind, they weren't making a lot of noise. she told them that they can only sit outside if they order pizza, but her store was closed. how does this make sense? pizza nova is the better option. such nicer people and crispier pizza. The owner is also quite rude and called my friends the R slur. they don't wash their hands when prepping the pizza. no gloves either. There's little room to sit and it's not clean. the floor is filled with dust that looks like it hasn't been cleaned in months. Even though it's cheap, it's unsanitary and discusting.
Oct 11th, 2023