Church Street Catering

After weeks of looking for my upcoming 40th Birthday party! and several chats with Catering owners! I found Cheryl! and it was the BEST decision ever! She is so kind and welcoming! takes her time to speak with you and listen all your questions/concerns! for my party I wasn't looking for a seatdown dinner or buffet style! my party was a lounge Bar party so I was looking for small bites through several hours and full bar services! She Nailed! I didn't have to think or be worried about anything because she took care even to call people to sing happy birthday to me! I HIGHLY recommend her SERViCES! fabulous person! Fabulous staff!!!! THANK YOU CHERYL for making my party a total Success!!!
Nov 4th, 2023

We hired Church Street Catering for our baby shower. They not only provided delicious food and service, they also secured the venue along with all rental items and very upscale serving pieces. The passed appetizers are all homemade and of top quality - think 5 star restaurant level. The lunch buffet included chicken and seafood for main courses along with a pasta and vegetable side. All of the food was fresh and well presented. Desserts were also on point and homemade. The overall presentation was among the best that I have seen.Cheryl and her team went far and above and beyond to make this event truly special for our family, and we will be forever grateful!
Nov 6th, 2021

I just hosted a fabulous party to honor my Hubby's Milestone Birthday in our Glen Ridge home.  Cheryl at Church Street Catering did a super job making a party for 70 guests in our home a huge success!  She guided me through selecting diverse yet complementary choices from an expansive menu ensuring a balance of delightful dishes both passed and stationed that would appeal to every guest's tastes and desires.  She never pushed a one from column A, two from column B format and she encouraged my creativity while staying mindful of the projected party budget.  She was professional and pleasant as was her highly skilled staff.  It was such a wonderful night and my guests and my Hubby had a great time!  I will definitely use Cheryl and Church Street Catering again and I recommend them without reservation.  A good time was had by all and only two weeks since the party I have had 3 requests from friends for her contact information!
May 20th, 2019

May 14th, 2019

We recently had a terrible experience with Cheryl at Church Street Catering for our daughter's Bat Mitzvah. We were shocked at the unprofessional way the party was handled the week leading up to the event. Food was cold, and mediocre at best.  Feel like we got ripped off!
Apr 4th, 2019