Mahoney's Atlantic Bar & Grill

Wonderful restaurant....with a large bar area in a separate area. We split a large ceasar salad between 3...it could have fed 4 or more. Scallops were plentiful... Lamb chops were seasoned perfectly....over white beans....and the asparagus was cooked perfectly as well. The steaming bowl was full of seafood over a small amount of pasta. The broth was exceptional as was the service.
Feb 24th, 2024

Feb 11th, 2024

Their blackened tuna was delicious. It is a light portion though, so if you do not have an apetizer, you may still be hungry after. The shredded carrot and root that it comes with is not filling enough. It could use an extra side. The staff was nice and helpful. But the wait to be seated is way too long. They should really take reservations. Especially considering the number of seniors and elderly customers they get. Someone's elderly mother (with a walker) passed out and was taken in an ambulance because she had been waiting standing for over 75 minutes! And there really is not much space to wait. It was crowded. At least let the elderly people make a reservation...
Feb 10th, 2024

Feb 7th, 2024

An enjoyable surprise! Our son has been very pleased every time they've dined here! Food was excellent! Service from Debbie was great as were her recommendations! Deserts were outstanding! This should be everyone's must try dine list when visiting Orleans/Brewster area!
Jan 28th, 2024