Old Smith Farm

Mackensie Russell _{on Google}

Mar 1st, 2024

We decided to drop some dough on some pies at Old Smith Farm Shop and when I tell you easily the best pizza Ive ever eaten. Buffalo chicken Gorgonzola, broccoli chicken with mushrooms, and gluten free pepperoni were absolutely demolished. This is the second closest pizza joint to where I live and I will spend money and go further to get their pizzas any day. 88$ for three pizzas after the tip and it was worth every penny. The atmosphere in the shop is so cute, the owner was very friendly, talkative, and inquisitive, and she was happy to tell me all about their summer operation. I am very much looking forward to warm weather as a recent transplant and Im excited to see how live the place gets.

Marie G _{on Google}

Sep 29th, 2023

Great food, great music. Highly recommend it.

Andrew Miner _{on Google}

Sep 22nd, 2023

The barn is a charming indoor venue with a neat a little deck and sprawling back yard with picnic tables and fire pits. They've got an interesting cocktail list, however the consensus at our table was that most of the drinks were overwhelmingly sweet.
The starters (eggrolls, cauliflower, and brussels sprouts) are all fantastic. Also enjoyed the fish & chips, and the burgers were cooked well but the bacon was meh and it could have used some sauce. The kale caesar salad was flavorful but very tough, and lacked that crouton crunch you want in a caesar. The lemon linguini was quite citrusy, but very watery and plain otherwise.
It's a fantastic venue with good staff but the quality - and in some cases the portions - of the food and drink do not match up with the quite shockingly high prices. Despite that feedback, I would recommend a visit if you don't mind a little sticker shock, especially if it's a nice evening and you can enjoy the lovely outdoor space.