Tipsy Mermaid Conch House & Cocktails

Apr 8th, 2024

Amagansett sucks. This place rocks.
Apr 7th, 2024

Place is great for food and a cool ambiance. If you actually use Google reviews to try and get a feel for restaurants, please disregard the one star reviews here from people upset about something unrelated to the food and atmosphere. Have been here multiple times and have had no issues at all. Highly recommend.
Apr 5th, 2024

Sydney the bartender was amazing! So fun & made the best dirty martini weve ever had! That girl deserves a raise for how above and beyond she goes! Also the key lime pie was fantastic!
Apr 5th, 2024

Someone asked for good seafood restaurant suggestions, in a foodie group I'm in, & out of the different places people mentioned..the Tipsy Mermaid caught my attention. It was the only place that I wasn't really familiar with & with a name like that.. I had to check it out. I was surprised that they didn't take reservations & even though it was around 8:30 on a Friday evening.. there was no wait. Very casual, cool, atmosphere. March Madness games were playing at the bar & several staff members came to check on us throughout the course of the evening. Being pescatarian often limits our dinner choices, but this place had more options than I knew what to do with. Everything that we ordered was great, but I'm already looking forward to going back again because there were so many other things I still wanna try.. it's actually probably gonna take a few more trips because there were just that many delicious looking choices. I'm glad I stumbled across this place & I will be going back.. SOON. Vegetarian options: I didn't get a vegetarian dish this time, but on my next trip I want to try their mushroom gnocchi.. it looked delicious. Parking: There was parking on the street, but we were able to find a spot, on their lot, directly behind the restaurant.
Apr 4th, 2024