Bruster's Real Ice Cream

We used to come here all the time because their sherbet is amazing, especially the pina colada, orange, and cherry. Unfortunately, they never have these anymore. We check the menu daily in hopes of being able to return to enjoy a sherbet, but most days they don't have any sherbets on the menu at all (only ices) or they just have black raspberry. We have been checking for months now and they haven't had them. In general, their menu changes very little in comparison to when they originally opened. I don't know why they don't have much of a variety or make sherbet anymore. It's a shame because we live so close and would come here a couple times a week.
Jun 17th, 2023

Jun 2nd, 2023

I just came from Dairy Queen in Fishers on 37. Being on a motorcycle I had to go inside. I stood at the counter (1st in line) for TEN minutes! No hello, no welcome to DQ, we will be with you in a minute. NOTHING from the 6 employees working!!! All they seemed to care about were the drive-thru customers. I left and came to where I am now, at BREWSTER'S just 10 minutes east on Olio Rd. OMG! FAST SERVICE and their vanilla malt is TWICE as big for the same price! Needless to say, Bruster's is my #1 place to come to!
May 28th, 2023

Horrible service, 4 people working with one line taking orders.
May 18th, 2023

Best ice cream and kindest workers
May 13th, 2023