Bake HomeMade Pizza Evanston

Place is not run well at all. Got NO cooking instructions. Only one person had a clue what they were doing. But the wort part was how DIRTY the place was. Disappointed.
Apr 27th, 2023

I have ordered regularly from Bake 425. Tonights service was horrible!! They got my order wrong. When I went to pick it up, they informed me they were out of nuts for the pear blue cheese salad. They gave me the wrong pizza which I didnt discover until I got home. When I called to report the mistake, they asked me to return back to the store. When I arrived, again, key ingredients were not available for the pizza. We asked for some type of compensation such as a free cookie or comping the pizza. We dont do that, said the employee. Its sad how the service quality has completely declined.
Dec 21st, 2022

Best pizza ever
Dec 12th, 2022

Very good first visit for a take home to bake pizza and a salad.  Anything Goes Monday $22.95 for a large speciality pizza and a small salad is pretty hard to beat!  We had the chicken pesto pizza (pistachio pesto, mozzarella, chicken, spinach, cherry tomatoes and shaved parmesan) and the spinach salad (with dried cranberries, feta and pine nuts, hold the red onions). The pizza toppings were all very fresh with juicy halved tomatoes and especially tasty with the legit shaved parmesan.  Overall it was good, but a tad shy on the chicken.  We had 4 pieces leftover from 2 adults. The salad was also very good with crisp spinach and the raspberry vinaigrette was not sweet thankfully - more like a balsamic vinaigrette.  The small salad was adequate for 2 people with the pizza. Had trouble getting through on the phone to order (online ordering not available):  I started trying around 3 pm and they finally answered a little after 4, even though the posted hours say 2 pm. They promised it to be ready in 20 minutes and it was. I will definitely return for the Monday special, but a $26 regular price for the same pizza that you bake at home seems pricey to me ($19 regular price for a large cheese - 14").
Jul 24th, 2022

May 13th, 2022