Fat Man's Cafe & Catering

Quaint historical setting with nice ambiance. We enjoyed the the wait staff was courteous and attentive. The food was very good.
Mar 30th, 2024

Mar 28th, 2024

Disgusting!!!!! Mac and cheese tastes like mayonnaise now. This place used to be awesome. They ruined the squash casserole the same way too. Why change good recipes?. Given you two more opportunities hoping someone just didn't know what they were doing one day and had an accident. But it's intentional judging by my reaction and the other reactions on your comments. Switch back before losing all your customers.
Mar 22nd, 2024

This is a fun place to have lunch. With an extensive, eclectic menu there's something here for every taste. I like the brick walls of the old warehouse and the informal atmosphere. Plenty of fodder here for the budding photographer. The friendly staff add to the enjoyment of the duning experience.
Mar 20th, 2024

Have to update my previous 5 star review. This place has went downhill over the past few years. The biggest issue is they keep changing recipes for staple items. Ordered Tuna sandwich all the time, then they got rid of it. We ordered the squash casserole every meal we ordered and on holidays, then about 3 years ago they completely changed it, started adding mayo or something similar and it's horrible. Stopped coming here. It was my favorite. Now I give them another chance and sometime in the last year they've done the exact same thing to the mac and cheese. Tasted like a spoonful of mayo. My wife and I just threw it in the trash, it was disgusting. Stop messing with good things. At least the pot roast hadn't changed.
Mar 14th, 2024