Edible Creations Cakes

I am so disappointed I didnt read the reviews BEFORE placing my order and paying. Im writing this in hopes that you (the future disappointed customer) heed my warning and advice to read the reviews before hiring and or paying any kind of down payment. I had 2 very big birthdays coming up this year in March only one 1 day apart from one another. My daughters 16th birthday, and my fathers 80th birthday. Normally, every year we always go to Publix with our cake orders as they are not only beautiful cakes but delicious as well. This year however, I was going to be throwing my dad a pretty large surprise party where the cake was going to be the centerpiece of the party and I knew Publix wouldnt be able to make such a complex and customized cake. My dad has this saying that he has been the same size since Highschool when referring to the fact that hes had a 30 inch waist since as long as he can remember. So, i had googled to find an image of a cake close enough to the one in my mind for a cake decorator to run with and then proceeded to do something hunting for a local company that could make the dream a reality. Thats when i stumbled across Edible Creations. I left a message with them and the owner Lily got back to me the next day. I messaged her my reference photo and shared the ways that Id thought shed be able to tweek it to be able to suit my dad best. Originally shed quoted me $280 for simply the sheet cake with a pair of jeans made of fondant laid over a butter cream background. **Attached is reference photo Id sent to her with pink background.** I told her that I didnt want to spend almost $300 for the cake so I was willing to compromise as long as she was able to get the point across with this cake. What we ended up with was SO EXTREMELY DISAPPOINTING I do not even have the words to articulate. First and foremost it was sloppy as hell. Second, the blue Lily used on the entire cake stained every single bit of skin it came into contact with. The taste of the cake was lackluster to say the least. I had chosen vanilla and chocolate with a dolce de leche filling of which when I finally ate the cake I tasted none at all. When everything was said and done I had paid $187.25 for a cake I wouldnt have even paid $20 for to begin with. I was so busy the day of my dads party that I sent my cousins to go pick it up. They took 1 look at the cake and hurried to send me a picture knowing that it wasnt at all what I wanted. My mom went ahead and made a phone call to Lily personally after the cake made it home to my house before my dads party. Simply just to make her aware of our thoughts. Not asking for a refund. You might ask, what was Lilys response to my mom telling her that her paying customers were really disappointed with this cake? The answer would be extremely defensive, dismissive, and abrupt. I will never again hire edible creations. In fact because of this situation I dont think I will ever again stray from Publix.
Mar 26th, 2024

The customer service/communication is not the greatest. I tried since June to order 1-2 dozen sugar cookies after I tasted the cookie at a previous party. They were soft, moist and decorated beautifully. After voicing my concerns as a comment on their Instagram page, they finally said we can make them. I wouldnt have went through this if the cookies werent good. So I pick my 2 dozen up today and they werent as expected. They were hard and not moist. The decorations were nice but thats it. Its really sad that I went through all of this, paying $2.50 per cookie for it to be a bust.
Nov 17th, 2023

As always we do, we trusted Eddible Creations Cakes to design and make our Grand Twins 3rd Birthday Cake. What was my daughters dream was perfectly executed in a magic way! Everything looked beautiful and tasted even better. Loved how much care was put into designing and elaborating such piece of art. The whole experience from start to finish was excellent. We always recommend this business to anyone interested in getting the best cake in town!!!
Sep 6th, 2023

Their customer service is terrible. I found them by googling them and found they do cake push pops (per their website) which is why I contacted them, then sent multiple weird emails and said they dont do that. They are advertising things they dont offer. Highly dont recommend.
May 11th, 2023

Choosing Edible Creations to make our wedding cake was an easy decision. When we went for our cake tasting, my husband and I were blown away by the number of choices that we were given. We fell in love with their lemon cake with buttercream frosting. It was exactly what we wanted for a summer wedding. It was so moist and refreshing! The entire night guests were coming up to us to ask where we got our wedding cake. Everyone absolutely loved the lemon flavor! It looked just as beautiful as it tasted. We requested a beach theme wedding cake and Edible Creations definitely delivered. It was covered with beautiful shells, starfish, and bubbles. When the cake was accidently delivered without the brown sugar sand, the owner from Edible Creations immediately came by to add the sand. They even allowed us to make the top tier of our cake a different flavor without extra cost. We chose to make it pineapple. Traditionally the bride and groom are supposed to save the top tier for their one year anniversary, but my husband and I couldnt resist. The pineapple was so delicious! We plan on going back to Edible Creations on our anniversary to order another cake. It was so good!
Aug 25th, 2023