Andy's Pizza Restaurant

The fact that he is trying to entice people to buy disgusting old gumballs from the gumball machine in hopes of winning a slice of pizza says a whole lot about this place. He cant even accurately give a timeframe of how long it takes to cook a pizza, and isnt man enough to apologize when it takes much longer than he said. Edit to update: Your false report to Uber has already been documented. I didnt post about your food. Service and Atmosphere were all I clicked on. I didnt post about your food since I would never eat there. You LITERALLY have the WORST google rating out of every single pizza place in West Haven. Why would anyone order from a pizza place that has a 3.4 Google rating is beyond me. A 2.2 on Yelp! Wow! Even a 2.6 on your own Facebook page. That takes some hard work to get reviewed that low.
Apr 5th, 2024

They are scammers. I ordered 4 slices and 2 can sodas . They have a board up with prices and it clearly says $3.00 a piece for cheese pizza and the can sodas are $1.25 each. I ordered 4 slices and 2 can sodas. The guy behind the counter said my total was $16.10. Clearly that adds up to &14.50. I then asked him you guys charge taxes on your food? He then says to me we all pay taxes. Rude much. Smh. That would be a whole $1.60 for taxes sir. He said the sodas are $1.50 each. I said thats not what it says on your price broad. He stated we have to change it. Lol. Ok even with the sodas being $1.50 each the taxes is still $1.10. No way. My son had to catch the train and that was the closest pizza spot so I ended up paying for it. Never will visit this location again.
Feb 7th, 2024

Feb 3rd, 2024

Good food
Jan 27th, 2024

Jan 12th, 2024