Nostalgia

This store exceeded my expectations and was such a joy to shop. I collect toys both new and old, and believe me when I say there are plenty of both! There were toys from my childhood ('90s and '00s), my oldest sibling's childhood ('70s and '80s), and even back from my parent's childhoods ('60s and '70s). I ended up expanding on some of my collections and killing lots of time just looking at all of these wonderfully kept relics. But if you're not looking for vintage, don't worry- you could just as easily bring a child here and have them pick out a toy or stuffed animal that they'll love, like Trolls or Minions or L.O.L dolls (to name just a few). I would recommend this store to anyone and everyone- the prices were fantastic, the owner was such a sweetheart, and most of all, it lives up to its "Nostalgia" name.
Mar 17th, 2024

i like Monster High dolls and bratz dolls and Barbie dolls but i am a big collector of my little pony i like go to nostalgia-pelham toys shop
Feb 19th, 2024

Went to the shop for the first time today, saw it on Facebook and decided to check it out. The store was clean, the owner is super nice, and the toy and collectible selection was great, will definitely be returning!
Jan 20th, 2024

This place is a thrifters dream! Everything is so organized. Each item has a place so if you know what youre looking for, its easy to find. Pricing was so fair too, compared to other thrift stores in the area. Huge fan :)
Nov 14th, 2023

I really liked it, they have good prices and they serve very well, I will definitely return :)
Oct 21st, 2023