Keystone Rare Coins

Misty Riedel _{on Google}

Apr 4th, 2024

The proprietor is very knowledgeable and considerate. He is transparent in all his dealings. He was gracious to my mother and I, and made sure we were comfortable with the transaction and items we were willing to sell or hold on to.
There is no other place I would take my business.

Judith Evans _{on Google}

Mar 3rd, 2024

I was pleased with my visits at Keystone Rare Coins. The employees were welcoming and pleasant. Buddy was knowledgeable and trustworthy. I would simply suggest having a seating area where people could sit while they wait to be helped.

Alice _{on Google}

Feb 24th, 2024

The owner, Buddy Kellar, was great! Very professional. Reviewed the coins we had and gave us an extremely good offer. We will use his business in the future.

dex _{on Google}

Feb 17th, 2024

The man who waited on us named Buddy did an amazing job and gave us more than a fair price. Very trust worthy and honest gentlemen!

P C _{on Google}

Jan 30th, 2024

One of the worst buying experiences that Ive had at a coin store in over a decade. This store is not interested in selling any coins. Extremely rude owner and staff was not interested in taking any coins out to look at. Wasnt greeted and had to specifically ask the staff in order to get their attention to even show interest as a customer. I cant speak on if I were to sell to the store but if their offers are as bad as their customer service, I would 100% recommend going elsewhere